I’ve been watching the original (and superior) Battlestar Galactica with my grandkids, and it’s fun to see it through their eyes. I subsequently learned that creator Glen Larson included a lot of Mormon stuff in it, but even after watching it as an adult on DVD, it didn’t bother me. I think religion should have a place in science fiction (or space fantasy), and the strangeness of Mormonism (“sealing” rather than marrying, for example) actually enhanced the setting.
Of course the show was still built around traditional values of honor, courage in the face of impossible odds, and the spirit of adventure. The cast came to inhabit their characters, and while the episodes are uneven, it has held up quite well and I feel very comfortable showing it to a younger generation, who (no surprise here) love adventures of Boxey and his daggit.
I was therefore fascinated to learn that one of the creators for Amazon’s bizarre The Rings of Power, J.D. Payne, is also a Mormon. If so, he may want to talk to his bishop because the morality of the series is deeply twisted. The current season features a bi-sexual threesome involving a married couple, and of course Elrond made out with his future mother-in-law in a previous series, so there’s all sorts of weirdness going on.
I have read that contemporary LDS Church is having something of a crisis of morality in terms of increasingly Jesuitical (heh) interpretations of its rules, leading to the rise of “soft spouse swapping” as well as the practice of “soaking” (and the bestie willing to shake the bed) among the college set. (I’m just going to leave it to you to look those up.)
Then there is the whole business of “hot drinks” being forbidden to the faithful, along with alcohol and tobacco. It turns out “hot drinks” mean coffee or tea, regardless of their temperature, and that while caffeine was assumed to be forbidden (and many Mormons abstain from it), it has been “clarified” that this was never the case, and Brigham Young University added caffeinated soft drinks to their campus in 2017.
This is but one of many instances where “clarifications” or “new revelations” have unwound previous teachings, such as polygamy being initially encouraged and later prohibited and the flip-flop regarding the morality inter-racial marriage and the eligibility of non-whites to join the LDS Church.
Larson was of a generation where the rules had been stable for a long time, but that is no longer the case. From Joseph Smith, Jr. to Brigham Young and the subsequent President-Prophets, there was a lot of behavior and teachings that are now deeply problematic, and many of these have been quietly rolled back. Mormonism is highly malleable.
A key takeaway is that who you are is more important than what you do. If you are a person of importance (like Galadriel), the fact that you made out with a guy is no obstacle to him marrying your daughter, and if she cheats on her husband while he’s imprisoned with the incarnation of ultimate evil, well, that’s offset by Sauron and Celeborn having their own sordid affair.
Needless to say, absolutely none of this has anything to do with anything Tolkien wrote. It’s more in the line of Evelyn Waugh’s most vicious satire, particularly Lord Basil Seal seducing married women or eating a girlfriend (not intentionally, she was in the hot pot the natives served to him).
Similarly, why would orcs not be redeemable? Black people got let out of Mormon theological jail in the 1970s, so maybe there could be decent, civilized orcs who write poetry and stuff. Remember, Mormons venerate Eve because she defied God and thereby allowed people to have children and created the need for Christ’s saving crucifixion. Far from being Original Sin, it was a fortunate transgression, a happy mistake, sort of like how all of Christianity vanished until it was discovered in upstate New York via gold plates you are absolutely not allowed to see.
Mormons regard the Catholic Church as its arch-enemy (and yet are surprised that Catholics don’t recognize them as Christians), which makes J.D. Payne being so closely involved rather curious. Hiring a Mormon to write a Tolkien adaptation is not quite on the same level of hiring an Iranian mullah to produce a docu-drama on the origins of Hannukah, but it’s also not that far off.
Leave a Reply