Support Assistant

The official web site of A.H. Lloyd

In defense of the Novus Ordo (i.e. modern Catholic) Mass

One of the things I enjoy about participating in Becoming Catholic is to see how converts come to understand the depth and richness of Catholic Mass. It is not a mere “Sunday service” but an ancient rite handed down through countless generations with its roots in the beginning of time itself.

It is sad that a faction of Catholics regularly denigrates it. I mean, I understand that some people really get into the traditional Latin Mass, and at some point I will experience it, but a properly done Novus Ordo Mass is a deep religious experience, and its critics must keep in mind that its accessibility is one of the things that makes it easier for Protestants to understand our faith.

Indeed, talking with one of my friends (who is converting) who has attended both, he finds the TLM a bit much, and hard to grasp given his background. It is beautiful, but too alien for him wrap his arms around it. The regular Mass is much more meaningful to him, and compared to the Protestant services he used to attend, quite complex to the point of being somewhat intimidating.

Indeed, traditional Catholics in a lot of ways seem to be wanting to “level up” in their worship, which is great, but it’s a tough ask for someone who has grown up with Church as entertainment built around charismatic sermons and contemporary music in an arena-style environment to go directly to Latin chants.

Fanaticism about the TLM also leads to schism, as the Society of St. Pius X has demonstrated. In the runup to their illicit ordinations of bishops, the SSPX issued several statements essentially saying that it was the Church that was wrong, and they could do whatever they wanted because they now had legitimacy. This is not new, and there is a reason its founder was excommunicated.

As I remarked in my previous post about the absurdity of ordaining female clergy, you cannot defend traditional orthodoxy by violating it, and throwing a string of “whatabouts” does not justify direct and open defiance of Papal authority. The is a strong whiff of Yard Sign Puritanism about the SSPX.

While much blame on Catholicism’s decline is laid on Vatican II (complete with charts showing steep declines in Mass attendance), those must be compared with other denominations, because all of the Mainline Protestant churches have under gone severe demographic collapse. Evangelical churches are growing because they are picking up the strays who are now carving out their own special niche, and they punch below their weight because they have almost nothing in common with one another.

And yes, “easy button Christianity” is attractive to a great many people because you can decide what counts as sin, which in practice means carving out exceptions for the things you really like regardless of what Scripture or tradition say about it.

The result is the re-paganization of the West, perhaps with Christian trappings, but functionally the same.

The solution is to re-Christianize the West, and the means is by sharing the Gospel and the Church’s traditions. The most accessible way to do this is in the language of the people involved.

I get that many young people especially are drawn to the Church through the TLM, and that’s great, but I’d wager that even more are intimidated enough as it is by all the elements of the Mass, and both in my previous time as a sponsor and today there are a great many people worried that they won’t “get it right.”

Of course plenty of Catholics get things wrong from time to time, either because they are inattentive or having a bad day. I’ve missed a cue or fumbled a phrase from time to time because I’m human. We all make mistakes and what sets Catholicism apart are the Sacraments which provide remedies such as Reconciliation. Again, the Mass is only part of the equation, and groups that stress it to the exclusion of everything else are doing the Church – and the souls she could save – a grave disservice.

Leave a Reply